Melinda Livsey
Marks and Makers
https://www.marksandmaker.com
— [Transcription] —
[Chris Do] Hey guys, this is a special episode. I’m catching up with—you guessed it—with Melinda, and she’s here. And she’s had some tremendous growth. So I wanna talk to her, and, without further ado: Melinda, what has been going on with your life? Last we spoke, last time we spoke…LAST TIME WE SPOKE! She was like, “Chris! All my work is gone! What did you do to me? Are you trying to ruin me or what?” And I said, “You know: Stay with the plan, follow the process. Trust me, and I’ll take care of you.” So, wonderful things have happened.
[Melinda Livsey]: Yes.
[C]: You are leading the charge for a bunch of designers to start to charge for their knowledge. So I wanna hear kinda where you’re at, and then I’m gonna ask you a bunch of questions about how you got to be where you’re at.
[M]: Alright.
[C]: Give us the like the BIG update.
[M]: The big update, well, last time I was here we were here with Rebecca and I was saying how all of my leads had dried up and my work, and I was probably eating Top Ramen and something, ugh…
[C]: Oh, hush! HUSH!
[M]: Wasting away.
[C]: Top Ramen over Kobe steak! But yes!
[M]: But now! Yes! Yes! So since then, one huge thing that’s changed are the leads. The leads are coming in. I have a lot, a lot of leads, which now (and I’ve sold jobs at a much higher price), now I have to do them, and so I’m dealing with actually—
[C] New problems.
[M]: Yeah, new problems! Great problems! I’m not complaining, I’m very thankful. Um, but it’s a completely different—it’s a huge shift. A huge shift that just started…I would say right after Thanksgiving, I got all the leads.
[C]: So it does take time.
[M]: It took a while.
[C]: I just want to let everybody know: It does take some time. You all expect instant results. Like, if I do X, then Y will happen immediately. And it doesn’t work like that. Real life does not work like that. It takes time to, to prepare the soil, to, to plant, and then you don’t get the harvest for some time. So let’s just get into the nitty and the gritty, if you will. The nitty-gritty, which is: You’re getting a bunch of leads now, which is fantastic (we’ll talk more about how you got those leads), but let’s talk about charging more. Let’s just dangle the carrot out there for them.
[M]: Yeah.
@2:32
[C]: What do you mean that you’re charging more? Like, how much more? Where do you go from and where are you at now?
@2:38
[M]: I went from 1) not doing strategy at all (using a questionnaire as my “strategy,” I would say)…I mean, I wasn’t charging for that, and now I am charging. I’m leading with that. I’m actually selling that–I’m not really selling. I’m trying to align with my client. I don’t want to say sell because I’m not pushing anyone into anything. Um, I’m aligning with their goals and their problems, and I am offering them strategy first, really as the only option if they would like to work with me. And, um, I’m presenting it in a way that they’ve fallen in love with strategy, and then I’m charging for it. So that is a massive change from not charging for a questionnaire (which I DID call my “strategy”), to actually doing in-person workshops and selling that strategy. That’s a big difference.
[C]: Okay. I think you’ve done an excellent job of avoiding my question.
[M]: Well, repeat.
[C]: How much are you charging from–How much are you charging today relative to what you were just charging a little while ago? Can you give us an idea?
[M]: Well, it’s just completely different because the structure is different.
[C]: Well then, tell me about that structure and then the price attached to that structure then.
@3:48
[M]:Okay. So previously, I charged zero for strategy.
[C]: Right.
[M]: Now I charge (the last one) I’ve charged 5,000.
[C]: 5,000 bucks?
[M]: So I went from zero…
[C]: WOO!!!
[M]: …to 5,000 for strategy alone.
[C] Okay. So that’s a big number for a lot of people to process right now and some people are like: “Well, what is strategy? Like, what do you mean you charge 5,000 and why weren’t you able to do it before?” So we’ll spend a little time talking about this part. And I think the people want to know, ‘cause this is radically different because people are struggling in the streets, wherever you’re watching this, to even get four or five hundred bucks for a logo. And that’s like WORK. You’re talking about like getting paid to think.
[M]: Mm-hmm.
[C]: That’s a good problem to have.
[M]: It is.
@4:40
[C]: Okay. So let’s talk a little bit about that then. Um, in terms of, What is strategy to you now? We kind of understand a little bit about what you referenced before, but, now that you’re doing it, tell the people what it is.
[M]: Tell the people what it is. Okay.
[C]: Pretend like—okay—pretend like I’m a client.
[M]: Oh, man!
[C]: Like: Ding dong! Hey, Melinda! I wanna work with you. I saw your work!
[M]: Oh, role play! Again?!
[Laughter.]
[C]: You can’t avoid it!
[M]: Chris, you know how this turns out!
[C]: It turns out great every single time.
[M]: Yeah, every single time. It’s great! It, yeah…Well it’s…
[C]: Okay.
[M]: …Open to interpretation. Okay.
[C]: Okay, so—
[M]: Yes?
[C]: I’m just a brand new client. This time it’s gonna be really easy because you’re a super pro now, so, you know: Ring, ring! Here we go.
@5:18
[C]: I wanna work with you! I saw your website, I’ve seen you on all these podcasts, and your Instagram is amazing—I wanna work with you. How do we do that?
[M]: You wanna work with me? What are you looking for?
[C]: I’m looking to rebrand.
[M]: Oh! You’re looking to rebrand. Okay. So have you thought of a certain budget? Do you have a certain budget set aside for this?
[C]: I don’t.
[M]: You don’t. Well, okay. Typically, depending on the size of your company, marketing efforts are around 5% to 10%, depending on what your goal is, so, of your gross revenue, so, with that said, what’s your goal of rebranding? Why are you even…what makes you want to rebrand?
[C]: I just feel like it’s outdated, and you know, I hired some friend of the family who did it originally and it’s been okay, but we’re growing and I feel like when I look at what we do, I don’t feel proud of our identity. I’m not proud at all.
@6:19
[M]: And so, could you describe to me where you’re at currently? As far as where you want to grow? I hear you wanna grow, so that’s your ideal. And you want to continue to grow, so that’s your ideal. But you feel that you are stale or…Can you describe to me what that feeling is? Why do you feel that way about your brand?
[C]: Well, I’m gonna show you this: Does this look jenky to you? This feels like it’s not professional, it doesn’t feel like we’re innovative, it doesn’t feel like it’s reflective of what our value is. We’re an 80 million dollar company, and this looks like some kid did it, because in truth, some kid did do it. I want a professional touch. I saw the work that you do: It’s very classy, it’s very stylish, it’s very modern–that’s what I want for my company.
@7:05
[M]: Great! Well, it sounds like (from what I’m hearing) your ideal client…are they feeling the same thing that you are, too? Are you losing them? Are you gaining them?
[C]: Hmm, I don’t know. I think we would like to have more clients…We’re growing, so, I think we’re gaining clients and customers.
@7:25
[M]: Well, typically during this conversation, I would have something visual to show, and I would be writing down where you are (which is here) and then I would be writing down your ideal (which is there), so that they can see it visually and we’re both looking at something together. And then I would break it down where the middle (this is your aim), so I start asking you questions: “Well, what is this…What’s an attainable goal about midway between where you are now and where you wanna be? What would that look like to you?”
[C]: Well, you know, I don’t know yet. I mean, I just, really would like to start with the rebrand, so I’m thinking: we need a new logo, we need a new identity system, probably somewhere down the line, we’ll need a website to reflect all this stuff, but for right now, I think the identity is really important.
@8:06
[M]: Great, so, those are the tasks that will get us to that goal, [but] what does that goal actually look like for your company? Where is your company during that time? Is it–did your company grow in revenue? Do you want your company to grow as far as sales, as far as attracting a certain kind of customer? What does that look like? Because those things (the logo, the rebrand) are more of a vehicle to get you to the goal, or a task to get you there, but they aren’t the end goal. So they’re there to get you to your goal. So what would that look like for you?
[C]: Maybe I’m not understanding this: I just feel like things don’t look very good right now. And I feel like, if we could just do that, I’d be more proud to represent ourselves like, as we go out into the world. I almost feel ashamed. Like, I don’t want to even give you my business card right now. Do you know what I mean?
@8:58
[M]: Yeah, yeah. So then, an attainable goal that I’m hearing is that, it would be that you’re proud of your company, and that you would want to go around and that you want to be proud of it, that you want to show it off, you wanna feel that you are above your competitors. Right?
[C]: Sounds good.
@9:14
[M]: Well, this is how I do it! (And then, you would see visually, how strategy comes into play with that.) Strategy is the core that we have to start with, the next thing are objectives (so that would be something like UX, that would be marketing funnels, that would be goals (measurable goals), from there we have deliverables. And so, if we actually start with the logo first, we’re going to have a very shell of a brand, and it’s not going to be held up by anything because there’s no goals, and there’s no purpose. So we actually start with brand strategy first. And then you would see a goal, or you would see a diagram of that if you were sitting down with me.
[C]: Okay. This feels right. I feel like you’re the right person to do this. So, how much do you charge to do this?
@10:00
[M]: So typically, brand strategy is, it starts at 5,000 and it can range all the way to 15. And you would see also what those options would be.
[C]: Okay, and what do I get for that? Like, why do I have to do this?
@10:11
[M]: It sounds like you want to get to your goal and typically my clients, which in this conversation, we would end up seeing that you’re possibly not focused, that you’re trying to do several things at once, but not getting very far, and so I have some things to walk through to show that, and usually clients are like: Yes, I totally relate to that. So with that, focus and clarity are what I’m mainly leading with, with strategy, and so the first package is strategy to find out who the ideal client is, to know them very well, to also provide a marketing funnel strategy (so the overarching funnel of how does the client become aware of you, all the way to, how do they end up being an advocate for your company)? Because you want people to share and re-feed the funnel so that you don’t have to keep putting money in. So does that sound good? Put money back in to gain those ideal clients if they’re your advocates?
[C]: That sounds great.
@11:09
[M]: And we would also go over your brand, too, and who you are so that what you said about wanting to be confident in your brand and be able to feel like you’re above the competition, we would also nail down all the attributes, the positioning statement, the value proposition, in that early time so that we know where we’re going and you know where you’re going.
@11:30
[C]: That sounds all wonderful, but I just want you to do our identity. Can we just skip this process?
@11:36
[M]: Well, do you have a brand strategy already?
[C]: I have something, yeah.
[M]: You have something? And what does that entail?
[C]: Uh, I can send it to you after this.
[M]: Okay.
@11:51
[C]: Maybe I can kinda share with you what we have. It has a little bit about our mission statement, what some of our beliefs are…
@11:53
[M]: Okay. That more stands for something that is aligned with your business plan, and this is more aligned with how you reach your ideal client. So they’re a little bit different. And I work through this certain process, so if you’d like to work with me, then we do start at brand strategy.
@12:12
[C]: So you’re saying you won’t do this unless we hire you to do the brand strategy?
@12:17
[M]: That’s correct because I feel that I’ve actually used to do this, I used to be a freelancer and I used to take on the projects that were the deliverables, and I didn’t even think about what my clients’ goals were, and if we were reaching those goals, and if we were helping the client get to those goals, and it was–I ended up being an expense. And I don’t want to do that to my clients anymore, so I have switched over to the world of brand strategy because I want to align with my clients’ goals, and then have them align with their own clients. (So this is again, there is a diagram here where it shows “brand strategy,” “objectives,” and “deliverables.” So people typically come to me for the deliverables, but there is no goal or no strategy attached, so you don’t know if you’re reaching your goal. So then, it always ends up being an expense and not an investment.)
@13:08
[C]: Okay, you’ve given me a lot to think about here. So if this strategy part costs $5,000 dollars (and I hear a lot of people say this, so I’m not sure if y’all’s are saying the same thing), but if I have to spend 5,000 bucks, then okay. What’s the logo gonna cost me?
@13:26
[M]: The logo is going to cost you a minimum of 5,000 on top of the strategy.
[C]: Okay, a minimum. Okay, what would affect the price?
[M]: The complexity…the…(I’m breaking character.).
[C]: You, you can’t just decide when you want to break character!
[M]: Well, yes! I can! I can!
[C]: Yo! Yo! My brain can’t process like when you’re like: Is she breaking character?
@13:47
[M]: Well I have visuals, so we’re breaking my own process.
[C]: No, we’re just having a conversation.
[M]: I know, I don’t have this…I do visuals, yes.
[C]: Mmm. Alright.
[M]: So I go from initial…
[C]: I gotta coach you on how to do this without anything.
[M]: Well I, I have to do it with visuals currently because I have nothing on my site to show this, at all.
[C]: Well, it doesn’t matter.
[M]: Okay, well then…
[C]: You have it up here (*points to his head*)
[M]: Do teach, Master Do.
[C]: I will. I will, but let’s just finish this out though.
@14:08
[M]: Okay. So I’m just saying this because my process that I’m currently doing, this would not happen. Because I have case studies to show.
[C]: Okay.
[M]: And I have a process to show.
[C]: Okay.
[M]: So.

