5 Essentials For Gamifying The LinkedIn Algorithm w/Jocelyn Macdonald
Chris Do and sales expert Jocelyn Macdonald reveal the five essentials for gamifying the LinkedIn algorithm for massive reach.
Chris Do
Founder, The Futur™ · March 2, 2021
The Great Professional Replatforming
Most professionals are using LinkedIn wrong. They treat it like a digital file cabinet, a place to store a resume and collect endorsements like dusty trophies. It’s a static, passive strategy for a platform that has become anything but.
LinkedIn is no longer a sleepy corporate directory. It is the third horse in the social media race, and it’s running on a different track. While other platforms throttle organic reach and demand you “pay to play,” LinkedIn is still a place where quality content can earn massive, unpaid visibility.
As sales professional and LinkedIn strategist Jocelyn Macdonald explains, a seismic shift occurred during the global pandemic. Conversations between users jumped 55 percent. Content creation exploded by 60 percent. But the most revealing number is this: content on the platform now generates 15 times more impressions than job postings.
Read that again.
The platform’s primary function, in the eyes of its users, has changed. It is not about finding a job. It is about finding ideas, connections, and solutions.
“It used to be that we were on LinkedIn just for our resume,” Macdonald notes. “But no, people are going there for their news. People are going there to make connections.” For creatives, this means a platform once seen as sterile and corporate is now a vibrant gallery. “I love seeing design, I love seeing art,” says Chris Do. “There used to be very little of that and now I find that designers, creatives are being a lot more open about sharing their work and I love to see it.”
This is the new landscape. To succeed in it, you cannot use the old map. You need to understand the new rules of engagement.
Understand the Motive, Win the Game
To master the LinkedIn algorithm, you must first understand its motivation. It is not a benevolent force for good. It is a business engine.
“LinkedIn really does want to sell LinkedIn ads and premium accounts,” Macdonald states plainly. “That's how they make their money.”
This single fact is the key to everything. The platform’s goal is to keep users on-site for as long as possible to maximize the number of ads and premium subscription offers they see. Your goals and LinkedIn's goals must align.
“The more content, the more reach a post has, the more opportunities they have to sell ads,” Macdonald clarifies. When your content keeps people engaged, scrolling, and commenting, you are directly serving LinkedIn's business model. In return, the algorithm rewards you with more reach.
It’s a simple, symbiotic relationship. Your success is their success. Your failure to engage an audience is a failure for their bottom line.
This is a fundamental departure from the pay-to-play ecosystems of Facebook and Instagram, where organic reach is often negligible. On LinkedIn, your effort is still the primary currency. “As a content creator, I want to be rewarded for my efforts,” Do explains. “If I make something, I want people to see it. That's the whole point.”
This model is built on a foundation of trust. According to research Macdonald references, 73 percent of users say they trust LinkedIn with their data and privacy more than other major social platforms. This trust creates a more professional, focused environment, drawing in a user base of nearly 740 million people who have consciously decided, “This is important to my business.”
Before you can gamify the system, you must accept this core premise. You are a partner in LinkedIn’s mission to hold user attention. Stop fighting the algorithm and start feeding it what it wants: content that makes people stop, think, and interact.
Your Secret Weapon: The Social Selling Index
Most users are completely unaware that LinkedIn is grading them. Behind the scenes, the platform uses a proprietary metric to measure your effectiveness. It’s called the Social Selling Index (SSI), and it’s one of the most significant factors determining your content’s reach.
“Social Selling Index is kind of a system, a metric system that LinkedIn put together so people can have a little bit of a way to judge the strength of their profile,” Macdonald explains.
Your SSI score, which you can check for free by searching “LinkedIn Social Selling Index” on Google, is a number out of 100. It is composed of four distinct pillars, each worth 25 points.
- Establish your professional brand. This pillar measures the completeness and quality of your profile. It rewards a profile that is fully built out with a client-facing mindset, telling a clear story about who you are and what problems you solve.
- Find the right people. This is about the quality and focus of your network. Did you “just blanket connect with everyone,” as Macdonald asks, or have you been thoughtful in targeting your audience? The algorithm wants to see that you understand who you’re trying to reach.
- Engage with insights. This measures your activity as a contributor to the community. Are you sharing valuable content, commenting thoughtfully on others’ posts, and participating in relevant groups?
- Build relationships. This final pillar tracks your ability to connect with decision-makers and nurture your network. It’s about turning connections into conversations and, ultimately, relationships. As Do observes, this means helping people “in their business and in their life.”
A score of 75 or above is considered excellent. During the discussion, Macdonald reveals her score is 76, placing her in the top 1% of her industry. Do’s is 71. This score is not a vanity metric; it is a direct input into the algorithm.
A high SSI, combined with an “All-Star” profile rating, signals to LinkedIn that you are a power user. You are a valuable asset. When you post, the algorithm gives your content the benefit of the doubt, pushing it out to a wider initial audience because you have a proven track record of creating value.
Your SSI is a roadmap. It shows you exactly where you are deficient. Improving your score is not just about appeasing a machine; it is about building the fundamental habits that lead to success on the platform. It forces you to get clear on your brand, your audience, and your contribution, a process that is central to building a powerful personal brand.
From Static CV to Dynamic Brand Hub
Your LinkedIn profile is the foundation of your entire strategy. If it is weak, incomplete, or unprofessional, even the best content will struggle to gain traction. The algorithm judges your profile’s strength, categorizing it as Beginner, Intermediate, or All-Star. Your goal is nothing less than All-Star status.
This is not about simply filling in boxes. It is about transforming your profile from a backward-looking resume into a forward-looking brand statement. Macdonald breaks down the essential components.
First, your profile picture. “It’s your first handshake,” she insists. This means a clean, professional headshot. No wedding photos with a cropped-out cousin. For an extra edge, use a tool like remove.bg to create a version with a simple, solid-colored background that stands out.
Next is your background banner. The default images are fine, but a custom banner that complements your job title, industry, or personal brand is a mark of a pro. It’s a billboard for your expertise.
The “About” section is your manifesto. Macdonald stresses that this is not a “set it and forget it” field. It should be a living document. Crucially, it must be built around three to five strategic keywords that define your expertise and goals, such as “social selling,” “brand strategy,” or “creative direction.”
“Find your story, find your keywords,” she advises. These keywords should then be woven throughout your profile, from your headline to your job descriptions, and even used as the hashtags you follow to dial in your content feed.
Here are the non-negotiable elements for a complete, All-Star profile:
- Professional Profile Picture: A clear headshot of you alone.
- Custom Background Banner: A visual that communicates your brand or expertise.
- Keyword-Rich About Section: A compelling summary built around 3-5 core keywords.
- Featured Content: Pin examples of your best work, valuable articles, or projects you admire. Even if it's not your own work, feature content that reflects your perspective and taste.
- Detailed Experience Descriptions: Don't just list titles. Tell a story for each role, highlighting accomplishments, awards, and the value you created.
- Skills & Endorsements: List your core competencies to allow your network to validate your expertise.
- Recommendations: Social proof is powerful. Actively seek recommendations from clients and colleagues who can speak to your work.
- Interests: Follow relevant companies, influencers, and groups to signal your areas of interest to the algorithm and other users.
Building this profile is your first act of contribution. It tells the algorithm, and every person who visits your page, that you take this platform seriously. It is the first step in moving from a passive observer to an active participant whose personal brand does the heavy lifting for them.
The Unwritten Rules of LinkedIn Content
Once your profile is optimized, it's time to contribute. But not all content is created equal. The LinkedIn algorithm has strong preferences, and ignoring them is the fastest way to kill your reach.
The guiding principle comes from a familiar framework. “Educate, inspire, entertain,” Do says, borrowing his own philosophy. “So many people are on there just saying, ‘This is what we do, this is how we do it,’ and no one really cares.” The goal is to build trust and rapport. Value comes first; the sale comes much, much later, if at all.
The first technical rule is about where your content lives. Create native content. The algorithm despises outbound links. “LinkedIn doesn't want you to send traffic away from their platform,” Macdonald states. When you post a link to YouTube, your blog, or a news article, LinkedIn will actively suppress your post’s reach.
There are two primary workarounds to this penalty:
- Put the link in the first comment. Post your content, and then immediately add a comment containing the outbound link. Be sure to mention in your post, “Link in the comments.” The downside, as Do points out, is that the comment can get buried as engagement grows.
- Edit the link into your post. Publish your post without any links. Let it gain some initial traction, then go back and edit the post to add the link. This is a more advanced hack that can bypass the initial algorithmic penalty.
The second rule is about originality. Original content is always more powerful than a reshare. Simply hitting the “repost” button on someone else’s content yields horrific reach. “It's not going to help you as much,” Macdonald confirms.
Do offers a powerful hack for this. If you truly want to amplify someone’s post, don't just reshare it. “You should screen capture it and post the screen capture,” he advises. This makes it new, native content in the eyes of the algorithm. To do this ethically, you must also copy the original text, credit the author prominently by tagging them, and ideally add the link to the original post in the comments. This honors the creator while maximizing visibility.
This raises a critical point about content etiquette. Do warns against people who “literally will grab my carousels from Instagram and then repost on LinkedIn… you didn't even ask.” Taking content wholesale, even with credit, can disrupt the original creator's content schedule. Worse still is taking an idea and simply changing the images without any reference. “Practice happens in private,” Do says. Taking someone's work and passing it off as practice is a cop-out. When you publish someone else’s concept, you are doing something different than learning. You are performing, and you must give credit.
By producing valuable, native content that educates, inspires, or entertains, you align yourself with the core purpose of the platform. You become a creator, not just a consumer, which is exactly how to build content that people actually react to.
The Art of the Algorithm-Friendly Conversation
Posting great content is only half the battle. On LinkedIn, engagement is not a passive activity; it is an active, strategic process. The algorithm closely watches how you and your audience interact, especially in the first 24 hours after posting.
“If someone says, ‘Oh, great point, I love what you just said,’ you need to react to it,” Macdonald insists. But a simple “like” is not enough. “Don't just react, comment.”
Every comment on your post is an opportunity. When you reply, you double the engagement on that thread, signaling to the algorithm that a real conversation is happening. This pushes your post into more feeds. Your goal should be to respond to every single comment, especially within that critical first day. Even the choice of reaction matters. The newer “Support” reaction is reportedly weighted more heavily by the algorithm than a simple “Like.”
And yes, Macdonald confirms, “it's okay to like your own posts.”
This engagement-first mindset also applies to how you interact with others. If you want to connect with a high-level influencer or executive, cold-messaging them is a low-percentage play. A far more effective strategy, Do explains, is to engage with their content first.
“Interact with that piece of content. Be consistent,” he urges. “Don't say, ‘Cool, rad, bro, awesome.’ That makes you disappear into the noise.”
Instead, write something thoughtful. A two-sentence comment that shows you absorbed the content and have a unique perspective on it is infinitely more powerful. “If you do this consistently enough, eventually some idiot like me will see it,” Do jokes. When that influencer sees your name and thoughtful comments again and again, they start to recognize you. When your connection request finally arrives, they already know who you are. You’re not a stranger; you’re a valued member of their community.
Macdonald builds on this, suggesting you research the key people you want to connect with. “Go to their profile and see what groups they're in. Research the hashtags they've used. Try and figure out what circles that they live in and then do what Chris just said: show up in those places again and again.” This creates an organic connection before the first direct message is ever sent, a strategy that is fundamental to building the rapport needed to close deals.
Mastering Your Posting Cadence
Once you are creating and engaging effectively, the final variable to master is timing. When and how often you post has a direct impact on your reach.
“LinkedIn is going to more heavily weight your first post of the day,” Macdonald reveals. The algorithm wants to test your performance as a creator. It gives your first piece of content its best shot at success. If you post a second time on the same day, the algorithm will judge that post against the performance of your first one, often cannibalizing the reach of both.
The rule is simple: one post per day, maximum.
The research Macdonald has seen suggests a cadence of three to four times per week is optimal. More is not necessarily better. This gives each post room to breathe and achieve its maximum potential reach. When you see a clear drop-off in engagement on your last post, that is the signal to post again.
Time of day also matters significantly. While any weekday morning is good, there is an ideal window.
- The Best Time to Post: Tuesday through Thursday, between 8 a.m. and 10 a.m. in your target audience's time zone.
- The Surprising Secondary Window: Saturdays and Sundays. While it may seem counterintuitive for a professional network, many users, especially creative professionals, use weekends to catch up on industry news and inspiration.
However, both Do and Macdonald caution against becoming a slave to the schedule. Strategy is important, but authenticity and value trump all. “Don't get too rigid,” Macdonald advises. “If you have something to share, if it's valuable, if it's relevant, if it's going to help, if it's going to inspire, educate, or entertain, share it.”
Connection Is a Strategy, Not a Statistic
Finally, every tactic and strategy on LinkedIn converges on a single purpose: building genuine human connections. How you manage your connection requests is a direct reflection of your professional ethos.
The generic, automated message is an instant red flag. “I don't like the one that says, ‘LinkedIn suggests that we should be connected.’ I'm just done with you,” Do states bluntly. It’s a sign of zero effort.
To get your request accepted, especially by a busy professional, you must be human.
“Write me two sentences that tells me you're a human being and why you think we should talk,” Do says. A specific, personal reason for connecting is all it takes. Reference a recent post, a shared interest, or a piece of their work you admire.
Conversely, there are clear lines that should never be crossed. For Macdonald, an automatic decline comes when a connection becomes inappropriately personal. “As a female, I'll say I don't appreciate when people get too personal with me,” she says, advising all users to avoid commenting on physical appearance. “It happens all the time.”
For Do, the line is the immediate sales pitch. The moment a new connection’s first message is an attempt to sell something, he doesn't just decline; he blocks them. “If your first piece of correspondence with me is trying to pitch and sell me something, I will block you for sure.”
Managing incoming requests requires a filter. Here is a simple framework for who to accept and who to decline:
- Automatic Decline: Connections with empty or suspicious profiles.
- Automatic Decline: Requests with generic, robotic messages.
- Automatic Decline & Block: Inappropriate, creepy, or personal comments.
- Automatic Decline & Block: Immediate, unsolicited sales pitches.
- Accept: Requests with a short, personalized, and respectful note explaining the reason for connecting.
- Accept: Requests from people who have already engaged thoughtfully with your content.
Macdonald even offers a clever trick for spotting bots. She includes her nickname, “Joss,” in parentheses in her profile name: Jocelyn (Joss) Macdonald. Automated bots will often scrape the full name, addressing her as “Hey Jocelyn (Joss).” A human will notice the cue and simply say, “Hey Joss.”
This is not about hoarding connections. It is about curating a network. These are the modern rules of engagement, and they are essential for anyone hoping to leverage the platform for genuine leads, as detailed in discussions like LinkedIn DM secrets that get clients.
The LinkedIn algorithm is not a mystery to be solved. It is a system to be understood. It rewards value, consistency, and genuine human interaction.
Stop treating it like a chore. Stop using it as a megaphone for your services. Start treating it like a community you want to be a part of.
The algorithm doesn’t reward tricks. It rewards contribution.
TRANSCRIPT
Enjoyed this? There’s more where it came from.
Get insights on creativity, business, and design from The Futur.
You can unsubscribe anytime. By submitting, you agree to receive communications and to our Privacy Policy.
“You're doing something different.”
— Chris Do
Key Takeaways
Subscribe
Details
- Length
- 1h 11m
- Views
- 27,643
- Topic
- SOCIAL MEDIA